Bretton Woods Project - Critical voices on the World Bank and IMF

Jump to main content | Jump to sidebar | Jump to navigation menu



Doing Business not related to growth Letter to the Economist

Letter|Bretton Woods Project|7 June 2013|url
print|email |bookmark FacebookTweet thisdel.icio.usDigg!Stumble UponRedditGoogle BookmarksYahoo Buzz

Below is the full text of a letter sent to The Economist, an extract of which was published on 6 June 2013.


24 May 2013

SIR -

The future of "Doing Business" has nothing to do with World Bank President Jim Yong Kim's opinion of growth ("Stand up for 'Doing Business'", 25 May). You confuse growth with a set of indicators which many inside and outside the Bank find fundamentally flawed.

You argue that Doing Business "spurs countries to useful reforms". Unfortunately the report also spurs countries to game the rankings and to undertake sometimes damaging deregulation which may harm the prospects for the majority of small and micro businesses in developing countries. The Bank itself recognises that Doing Business is not a template for reform.

Second you claim it furthers understanding of "how legal institutions and regulations affect growth". Yet, ten years since its launch, there is limited evidence that the reforms Doing Business promotes are correlated with growth (with the exception of one - the length of time it takes to register a business). Its focus on one city, even in vast and diverse countries such as Brazil further reduces its usefulness.

Finally, complaints are not the preserve of China; most countries have criticisms, as well as civil society organisations including trade unions and small business associations. A 2008 evaluation by the Bank's own internal evaluation unit found the report flawed.

Neither "fear of losing funding" nor the desire to appease ideologically motivated interests should guide Mr. Kim on the future of Doing Business. He should use the current review to decide on the merits of the case.

Peter Chowla
Bretton Woods Project

Christina Chang
CAFOD

London, UK

Published: 7 June 2013 , last edited: 16 September 2013

Viewings since posted: 1475

Articles: 3465

Advanced article search
Search newswire and resources

New website launched

You are now browsing an archive version of the Bretton Woods Project's website. This site has not been updated since September 2013, but may be used for reference material as the nbew site is being developed. However we suggest you look at the new website:
http://www.brettonwoodsproject.org/

Recent briefings & reports

Memorandum to the International Development Committee: Inquiry on the Future of UK Development Cooperation  26 June 2013

The Doing Business review: a test of World Bank leadership 24 June 2013

Climate Investment Funds Monitor 7: April 2013  25 April 2013

Working paper: The private sector and climate change adaptation: International Finance Corporation investments under the Pilot Program for Climate Resilience  24 April 2013

The UK's role in the World Bank and IMF: Department for International Development and HM Treasury  13 March 2013

World Bank on jobs: a "significant departure" or "business as usual"? 13 February 2013

No item found

Latest IFI-related video

The World Bank and human rights abuse in Honduras 7 August, Social Justice Committee of Montreal

Subscribe

Bretton Woods Update, 6 emails/year:
highlights fulltext pdf
Alerts of new web content
Weekly newswire email

Email:


Bretton Woods Project on Facebook


home | subscribe | donate | search | help | contact


validate: | XHTML | CSS | RSS

powered by Action Apps | hosted by GreenNet | Credits