Bretton Woods Project - Critical voices on the World Bank and IMF

Jump to main content | Jump to sidebar | Jump to navigation menu

IMF push for MENA subsidy reforms Who benefits?

News|Bretton Woods Project|26 June 2013|update 86|url
print|email |bookmark FacebookTweet thisdel.icio.usDigg!Stumble UponRedditGoogle BookmarksYahoo Buzz

The IMF signed a deal with Tunisia in June, after its renewed attempt to lend to Egypt failed in April, while civil society remained concerned about the legitimacy and transparency of the negotiations.

An IMF report released during the April World Bank and IMF spring meetings in Washington cautioned that the Arab countries in transition "continue to face high political uncertainty and social pressures." It argued for "effective structural reforms" including promotion of "private-sector growth and international trade, as well as attracting foreign direct investment inflows." Also in April, IMF Middle East department director Masood Ahmed called for "reductions in inefficient spending on generalised subsidies and increased expenditures on targeted social safety nets, as well as boosts to public investment" in the Middle East and North Africa region.

IMF managing director Christine Lagarde, speaking in May, focussed on how subsidy reform is required to reduce income inequality and "help divide the pie more fairly", via "protecting and augmenting social spending" and "reform of energy and other generalised subsidies". Speaking at a civil society event convened at the April IMF spring meetings, Isabel Ortiz of the Initiative for Policy Dialogue at Columbia University revealed the "worrisome impacts [of] the elimination of food subsidies in a context where food prices continue to be historically high” adding that these lead to "irreversible impacts on children".

The IMF signed a deal with Tunisia in June, despite questions about the government’s legitimacy (see Update 85). A $1.7 billion two year stand-by agreement with Tunisia was agreed with approximately $150 million available for immediate disbursement. The first set of policies in the IMF programme aims for macro economic stabilisation through fiscal, monetary and exchange rate policies, including a reduction of untargeted energy and electricity subsidies. The second set of policies aims to address economic growth, including measures to address vulnerabilities in the banking sector and a structural reform agenda "to rebuild Tunisia's economic model by promoting private-sector development, lowering regional disparities, and reducing pervasive state intervention." The third set of policies aims to "strengthen social assistance strategies" and assess "the social impacts of the envisaged reforms", with an aim to reduce inequalities, however, according to the IMF, "social security and labour market reforms still need a lot of consensus building, with priorities yet to be developed by the authorities".

Egypt still negotiating

Negotiations in Egypt continue after a renewed attempt to reach a deal on a $4.8 billion IMF loan failed in April (see Update 84, 83, 82, 80), while civil society remained critical of the negotiations. Mohammed Mossallem of the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights wrote in an April paper that fuel subsidies reforms enacted this year in anticipation of IMF agreement led to an "immediate rise" in commodity prices, and a "diesel crisis with fuel shortages reaching a peak in March, the harvest season", leading directly to food shortages and "higher prices … ranging from 7 to 30 per cent".

Speaking at an IMF spring meetings civil society side event Mahinour El-Badrawi of NGO the Egyptian Center for Economic and Social Rights argued that despite the IMF’s claim that the national economic plan is 'home grown', it was not made public until after national CSOs brought the case to the national administrative court, requesting transparency in the negotiations. According to El-Badrawi the policies are similar to those of an IMF review of April 2010. She said: "Even as we hear about the need for belt-tightening, we find that every piece of legislation implementing the new economic plan is biased to protect large local and foreign capital-holders. This is the exact reverse of recommendations by human rights bodies to ensure the most vulnerable and marginalised citizens are the ones protected in case of crisis response measures."

A June blog by Mohga Kamal-Yanni of UK NGO Oxfam argued that the Egyptian government lacks a "clear economic vision" which is "causing public confusion over whether Egypt needs a loan at all". Furthermore, the proposed deal includes removal of fuel subsidies "despite the clear signs of unrest among ordinary Egyptians as they have already started to suffer the impact of the fuel crisis." Instead, civil society and academics have proposed alternative measures, including progressive taxation and removal of fuel subsidies for rich people and energy intensive industry, but the government and the IMF have failed to listen.

Published: 26 June 2013 , last edited: 16 September 2013

Viewings since posted: 3035

Articles: 3465

Advanced article search
Search newswire and resources

New website launched

You are now browsing an archive version of the Bretton Woods Project's website. This site has not been updated since September 2013, but may be used for reference material as the nbew site is being developed. However we suggest you look at the new website:

Recent briefings & reports

Memorandum to the International Development Committee: Inquiry on the Future of UK Development Cooperation  26 June 2013

The Doing Business review: a test of World Bank leadership 24 June 2013

Climate Investment Funds Monitor 7: April 2013  25 April 2013

Working paper: The private sector and climate change adaptation: International Finance Corporation investments under the Pilot Program for Climate Resilience  24 April 2013

The UK's role in the World Bank and IMF: Department for International Development and HM Treasury  13 March 2013

World Bank on jobs: a "significant departure" or "business as usual"? 13 February 2013

No item found

Latest IFI-related video

The World Bank and human rights abuse in Honduras 7 August, Social Justice Committee of Montreal


Bretton Woods Update, 6 emails/year:
highlights fulltext pdf
Alerts of new web content
Weekly newswire email


Bretton Woods Project on Facebook

home | subscribe | donate | search | help | contact

validate: | XHTML | CSS | RSS

powered by Action Apps | hosted by GreenNet | Credits